Getting into men’s jewelry can be an enlightening experience because you get to learn a bunch of interesting things, such as the difference between gold-plated vs gold-filled jewelry.
It’s not immediately obvious, even if you’re looking at one of each type in real life.
Do you have a preference between these solid gold alternatives? Do you even know the differences?
Most people wouldn’t because these aren’t exactly run-of-the-mill concepts. But, it matters what you choose, because it will determine whether your gold-tone jewelry can retain its color in the long run.
If your budget doesn’t permit you to choose solid gold, but you still love the look of gold jewelry, you’re gonna want to know the difference between gold plated and gold filled. Gold vermeil is yet another option!
So let’s go over all these differences.
What’s The Difference Between Gold Plated vs Gold Filled?
Here’s the short answer:
Gold filled pieces have about 2 or 3 layers of actual gold mixed with other metals.
Gold plated jewelry is made through the electroplating process, taking a base metal—brass, copper, silver—and then applying a thin gold layer on top.
Gold plated and gold filled pieces each have their pros and cons. Moreover, they aren’t the only options!
The Pros and Cons of Gold Plated, Gold Filled, Gold Vermeil, and Solid Gold Jewelry
If durability is what you’re after, then solid gold is your best bet (10k or 14k specifically, read on for why), followed by gold-filled and gold vermeil jewelry. Gold-plated jewelry is by far the least durable or long-lasting option.
Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of each.
Solid gold is obviously the best. It’s what all these other gold-like variants are trying to be. It’s your best option if you want jewelry pieces that last.
It’s also the most expensive, since it’s real and a precious metal. So if you have a limited budget, the cost would be your main con.
Another thing to consider is its karat count. Gold with a higher karat count has a deeper color and a more lustrous shine, but it’s also weaker. Also, any metal that isn’t pure gold has the tendency to tarnish with repeated wear.
Developing this patina isn’t necessarily a bad thing, of course. But if you want your 10k or 14k chain to stay shiny all the time, you have to put in the work to polish it.
So let’s figure out what the best alternative to solid gold is, taking into consideration cost, durability, and quality.
The main pro with gold-plated jewelry is that it’s generally cheaper than any other type of gold option. But, as with anything, you get what you pay for. Its main downside is that gold plating doesn’t last very long and tarnishes easily.
If you’ve ever seen a “gold” necklace turn your neck green… that’s what happens when the base metal oxidizes, causing a chemical reaction and leaving a green (or even black) residue on your skin.
With that said, there are varying degrees of quality when it comes to gold-plated jewelry. Opt for a gold-plated piece where the gold layer is at least 0.5 microns thick. The thicker the gold layer, the longer the life span of the gold-plated chain, which means your skin won’t turn green any time soon.
Gold vermeil is often confused with gold plating because it also entails adding a thin layer of gold to another metal. However, there are specific differences that make gold vermeil superior.
The base metal of gold vermeil is .925 sterling silver. Inferior / cheaper metals cannot be used. A gold vermeil piece uses a far thicker layer of gold (a minimum of 2.5 microns thickness), and the gold must be at least 12k.
This also means that gold vermeil is more expensive than gold plating.
Basically, gold vermeil is a leveled-up version of gold plating, and will last longer than standard plating. In the battle of gold plated versus gold vermeil, gold vermeil wins every time.
Can gold vermeil pieces turn your skin green? It’s possible, because after time, the consistent exposure to moisture and sweat will oxidize the silver.
However, in general, gold vermeil does last longer than gold plating, so as long as you take care of your gold vermeil jewelry (e.g. take it off before showering, do your best to avoid getting it wet, etc.) it should last for years without any oxidation or tarnishing.
Gold-filled jewelry is made by mechanically bonding solid gold to a base metal, often sterling silver.
Two big pros with this process is that, if taken care of, gold-filled jewelry can last as long as solid gold. And it’s slightly cheaper than solid gold.
The downside? Most jewelry owners today find this method too expensive and don’t offer gold-filled jewelry at all. Because of this, it can sometimes be so expensive, it might be worth just waiting a little longer and saving up for a solid gold option.
Solid Gold Vs the Other Gold Alternatives
If you’re going for a piece of solid gold jewelry, you first need to figure out the level of fineness, or purity, you want. This is measured in karats. (Gold vermeil is also measured in karats, by the way.)
What’s a karat, exactly? One karat is equal to 1/24 part of the whole (24 karats = pure gold).
Generally, 10k gold (10/24 parts, or 41.7% purity) is the most durable, yet has the least gold content. 14k gold (58.3% purity) offers an effective balance of strength and aesthetic.
And 18k gold (75% purity) is considered gold’s purest form while still being practical. It is often used for high-end jewelry, engagement rings, etc. However, because of its higher gold content, 18k gold scratches more easily than 14k or 10k gold.
24k gold, while actually the purest, is rarely used for jewelry. Pure 24k gold is very soft (meaning it bends and scratches easily), very intense in color (doesn’t look real, because most people are used to the fainter yellow color of 14k or 18k gold), and very expensive.
Now that you know the differences between 10k, 14k, and 18k gold, you can make the right decision when purchasing solid gold jewelry.
And of course, you have alternative options—namely, gold vermeil and gold plated—if you’re looking for a realistic-looking yet more affordable option.
Solid Gold, Gold Plated, and Gold-Filled Jewelry: Some FAQs
Does gold-filled jewelry tarnish?
Gold-filled jewelry specifically can retain its quality and appearance for up to 30 years with proper maintenance. But remember, all gold tarnishes (or develops a patina) to some degree. And all jewelry needs to be properly maintained—cleaned with a solution, wiped down with a polishing cloth, etc.
Many jewelry enthusiasts suggest that gold-filled jewelry will tarnish more easily if there are higher levels of other metals (like copper and silver). Gold itself is a generally non-reactive metal.
How long does gold jewelry last?
10k-18k gold jewelry can last forever with the proper maintenance. Gold-filled jewelry, also with the right care, can last anywhere between 10 to 30 years or more, depending on the other metals mixed in.
Can you shower with gold-filled jewelry?
Yes, you can safely shower with gold-filled jewelry. However, many jewelry experts advise you to take your jewelry off before showering—even your solid gold pieces. The rationale behind this is that showering with your jewelry can cause it to tarnish over time.
Which Gold Option Sounds Best To You?
Solid gold will always be the best option in any lineup. And in our opinion, gold vermeil would be your second best option.
Gold-filled jewelry could be a great option, but because it’s not always easy to find, plus its high cost (often comparable to some solid gold options), we can’t wholeheartedly recommend it.
The most affordable option would be gold-plated jewelry. Just remember there are different quality levels of gold plating, and in general, gold-plated jewelry simply isn’t as long-lasting as the other options.
Feel free to DM us on Instagram if you want to discuss or have any other questions about gold jewelry for guys!